fbpx
Breaking News:
In Depth Politics World

India’s Kashmir move: Two perspectives

India's Kashmir move: Two perspectives

Humanosity says…

Kashmir has long been a fault line that has blighted relations between Pakistan and India. It has led to several wars and the recent action by the Indian government to revoke its special status has generated intense debate within India itself. This in-depth article gives two perspectives from that debate….

India’s decision to revoke Article 370, which gave special status for the part of Kashmir it controls has caused sharp political divisions. In this article, two different views are put forward. One comes from Baijayant Jay Panda and Shashi Tharoor. The two responses stand alone and are not responses to each other.

The following are excerpts of the argument that each put forward.

Kashmir now has the potential to be infinitely better

Baijayant Jay Panda is a four-time MP and a national Vice President of India’s governing Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP)

It is hard to predict how a defanged Article 370 could in practice be any worse than the decades during which it prevailed.

That era saw well over 40,000 deaths in Kashmir as well as two wars and a limited conflict fought over the region by India and Pakistan. It also saw the brutal persecution of hundreds of thousands of its minority upper-caste Hindu Pandit community, who were forced out of the region in the 1990s as Muslim militancy grew.

‘The Kashmir move is a betrayal of democracy’

Shashi Tharoor is a Congress party MP and former diplomat

Many, however, worry that the short and medium-term damage caused by this decision will greatly outweigh the theoretical long-term benefits.

First and foremost is the violence to India’s democratic culture: the government has changed the basic constitutional relationship of the people of Jammu and Kashmir to the republic of India without consulting them or their elected representatives.

The legal sleight of hand employed here sends ominous signals to other Indian states: if it can be done to Jammu and Kashmir, it can be done to you in future.

Click here to read full article at www.bbc.co.uk

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

...Humanosity is asking for your support.

We are a small independant team of journalists who want to help people engage in the most critical, interesting and relevant issues of our time. At a time when people are so time poor we dedicated our time to scouring the web so that we can bring you content that matters. We also produce our own articles, podcasts and videos that mail to give you a deeper understanding of the key issues that effect all our lives and this is why we need your support.

If you like what we are doing and find our content interesting and informative please consider signing up for a subscription which costs $4.99 a month. As part of the launch of our new website we are offering a 2 month free trial for all those who choose to support us by taking out a subscription.

Please click the link below and follow the instructions - it only takes a minute.